A/B Testing Ideas for Email Marketing

a/b test of two emails

April 16, 2024

Email remains one of the most effective digital marketing channels for engaging customers and driving conversions. However, with inboxes flooded with promotional content, your emails must stand out and connect with your audience. This is where A/B testing comes into play, offering a methodical approach to refining your email marketing strategies.
Explore A/B testing and what variables you can experiment with to elevate your email marketing!

What is A/B Testing?

A/B testing, also known as split testing, involves comparing two or more variations of an email campaign element to determine which performs better. By systematically testing different variables, marketers can gain insights into audience preferences, behaviors, and engagement patterns, ultimately driving more impactful campaigns.

9 Email Testing Ideas to Try

Even small tweaks can make a difference, which is why split testing should be part of your email marketing strategy. We recommend testing only one variable per A/B test, so it’s easier to determine the variable’s impact.
If you test multiple variables at once, it can be difficult to tell which variable contributed to the results and by how much. Here are A/B testing ideas you can try out to fine-tune your email marketing:

1. Subject Lines

The first impression matters, and your subject line is often the deciding factor in whether an email gets opened or ignored. Test variations in length, tone, personalization, and urgency to determine what resonates best with your audience.
For instance, compare a straightforward subject line with a more creative or provocative one to see which generates higher open rates.

2. Email Copy

Getting recipients to open your email is only part of the equation. Your email content should be compelling and tailored to your audience's preferences so they're more likely to engage and click through.
Experiment with different messaging styles, call-to-action (CTA) placements, and word choices to gauge what prompts recipients to take the desired action. Additionally, test the use of storytelling versus direct selling to see which approach yields better engagement and conversions.

3. Design and Layout

Visual appeal is crucial in capturing recipients' attention and encouraging them to interact with your email. You can test variations in layout, colors, fonts, images, and the placement of elements such as CTAs and product offerings.
Determine whether a minimalist design or a more vibrant layout better resonates with your audience and drives higher click-through rates.

4. Interactive Elements

Incorporating interactive elements such as polls, quizzes, surveys, or GIFs can enhance user engagement and make your emails more memorable. Experiment with different interactive features to see how they impact click-through rates and conversions.
For example, compare an email with a static image to one with a GIF showcasing product features to assess which generates more interest and interaction.

5. Personalization

Tailoring your emails to individual recipients can significantly increase engagement and conversion rates. Experiment with personalization tokens such as the recipient's name, location, past purchase history, or browsing behavior.
Test different levels of personalization to find the right balance that enhances relevance without appearing intrusive or overly familiar.

6. Timing and Frequency

The timing of your email delivery can impact its effectiveness, as recipients are more likely to engage with messages when they're actively checking their inbox. Test different send times and days of the week to identify the optimal schedule for reaching your audience.
Additionally, experiment with email frequency to avoid overwhelming subscribers while maintaining consistent communication.

7. Segmentation Strategies

Not all subscribers have the same interests or preferences, so segmenting your email list allows you to deliver more targeted content.
Test different segmentation criteria such as demographics, purchase history, or engagement levels to tailor your messages to specific audience segments. Measure how segmentation impacts open rates, click-through rates, and conversions.

8. Mobile Optimization

With more people reading emails on mobile devices, it's essential to ensure your emails are optimized for smaller screens. Consider testing variations in mobile responsiveness, font sizes, and the placement of clickable elements to deliver a seamless experience across devices. Verify that your emails render correctly on various mobile platforms and email clients.

9. Social Proof and Social Sharing

Adding social proof elements such as customer testimonials, ratings, and reviews can instill trust and credibility in your brand. Test the inclusion of social proof within your emails to see how it influences engagement and conversion rates.
Additionally, encourage recipients to share your content on social media by testing different calls-to-action and incentives.

Test Your Way to a Higher ROI

A/B testing is a continuous process that requires experimentation, analysis, and iteration to refine your email marketing strategies continually. By systematically testing different variables and measuring their impact on key metrics, you can uncover valuable insights to optimize campaign performance and drive better results.
Remember to document your findings and apply them to future campaigns to ensure ongoing success in your email marketing efforts.
Book a free discovery call to put your email marketing on the track to success! See what targeted email campaigns and automation strategies can do for your business.
Editor's Note: This post was originally published in October 2020 and has been updated for accuracy and comprehensiveness.  

Did you like this post?

Sign up for our Tips and Trends list and we'll let you know each week when we have a new one.

Automate Your Email With ActiveCampaign


Web Design (26)
Web Development (35)
Misc. Website (21)
Search Engine Optimization (96)
Social Media Marketing (111)
Local Search Marketing (24)
Content Marketing (35)
PPC Advertising (32)
Digital Marketing (123)
Marketing Automation (26)
Sales Automation (21)
Company News (10)
Other (27)